View history Sherry E. Lyall (February 1959 - January 15, 1984; later Sherry Hart) was an American mother and murder victim. And that is, our investigation, is to determine who did that. July 24, 2003 Walter Jones, 54, shot. Sheila Price said, I didnt get to bury my baby. $5,000 REWARD for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person(s) responsible for thedeath of Deborah Gail Nunnery. Tax bases have not kept up with the demand for services, and so theres been the slow starvation of law enforcement.. While decomposition made it impossible to see external signs of strangulation, internally there were some signs that could indicate she was strangled. Kristin Bennett, Lumberton Police told the medical examiner to discard of the blanket she was wrapped inI didnt even finish high school, but I have enough common sense to think, when doing a murder investigation, that may have evidence.. Inside the cabinet was a nude and decomposing body that had been covered by a blanket. 2003 Human skull found, unknown age, unknown cause of death. At one time she wanted to be a veterinarian. And thats all I can say., Theres no change to the investigation. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. He is also the co-owner of a pop culture website called The Back Row and recently wrote the award-winning script for a short film called Indefinite Late Fee. Oct. 13, 1997 Frankie Fowler, 34, beaten. June 6, 1987 Eric Martineves, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Curiously, he did not take his service revolver or nightstick with him. These cookies do not store any personal information. Theresa Blackwell, 27, of Fayetteville was found beaten and possibly I would like to thank all of the people who worked for decades on my familys case. Instead, her body was found the same day as Christina Bennetts on April 18th in a trash can outside 702 E. 5th Street. 1. The 1972 killings of Bryce, Virginia and Bobby Durham were solved when the son of a former Georgia inmate recalled his father's violent stories to a local sheriff's office. 10, 1995, as he sat in his cab. Two former police officers told Bamonte that two days after Coniffs murder, their captain ordered them to toss a package containing a gun into the Spokane River. She is 56 and at the time was about 110 pounds. Deborah would sometimes stay with her parents although she had her own residence in Quail Run Trailer Park in Roseboro. However, it remains a mystery who ordered the hit. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. She had been hit in the head with a blunt object. Police officers make their living fighting crime and solving mysteries, but what happens when the shoe is on the other foot? May 7, 2019 Read More. (Source: Fayetteville Observer). July 22, 1989 Carolyn Faye Smith, unknown age, unknown cause of death. The body was that of 32-year-old Christina Kristin Bennett. Community United Effort . The following morning, three men were caught trying to sneak off the island on a ferry. Skip main navigation-A A A + Our Organization . On April 18, 2017, at around 9:30 am officers in Lumberton, North Carolina responded to a call of a suspicious odor in an abandoned house at 505 Peachtree St. Dec. 4, 1981 Unknown remains, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Road was shot to death on Greensboro Street on Sept. 15, 1985. Handcrafted with love by Georgia Lou Studios. Megan called Rhonda, I aint never seen her act out or nothing. Kristin Bennett, Lumberton Police told the medical examiner to discard of the blanket she was wrapped inI didnt even finish high school, but I have enough common sense to think, when doing a murder investigation, that may have evidence., In the autopsy report for Christina Bennett it reads: The grey blanket is disposed of at the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner at the request of law enforcement.. Will NN Williamsburg Airport survive long term? The Oscars will air on ABC and can be streamed on ABC.com and the ABC app as well as Hulu + Live TV, YouTube TV, AT&T TV or FuboTV. Afterward, the aliens returned Schirmer to his car and erased all memory of his experience on the spacecraft, though they did leave a red welt on his neck. NCBI and the Lumberton police department have spent thousands of hours on these cases and said they have conducted more than 500 interviews and knocked on more than 800 doors during door-to-door canvassing. 32-year-old Lisa Harden also had a history of sex work and on July 12, 2003, her body was found in the woods behind a warehouse off Chippewa Street. If you have information about this case, call the Kernersville Police Department (336) 996-3177. The same amount of hours. Throughout her early life, the family moved around, settling in Michigan before returning to North Carolina in, DISCOVERY: On September 19, 1990, a three-man inmate work crew discovered the decomposing body of an unidentified female along I-40 in Hillsborough, North Carolina. March 3, 1996 Robert Smith, 34, blunt force. Four years. There was not enough physical evidence to link him to the other murders, but they did stop after he was taken into custody, so it is very likely that he was indeed the Edgecombe County Serial Killer. During the melee, Officer Cardillo was shot with his own service revolver by an unknown assailant. AUTOPSY: An autopsy was performed upon the body being brought Marlene Lenthang is a breaking news reporter for NBC News Digital. deliberately started on Nov. 24, 1991. This Caldwell County North Carolina Most Wanted List posts the top 50-100 fugitive criminals on the run. The first victim reported missing was 29-year-old Melody Wiggins. Doyle Wheeler was called on to testify and claimed that Jacobs did have a history of racism and misconduct. Oct. 28, 1985 Richard Northup, 45, blunt force. It was called Operation Tarnished Badge and it found that people in the sheriffs office were involved in kidnapping, drug trafficking, and money laundering. The neighbors checked the trash can and when they opened the lid, they were shocked to see a human foot. Rhondas autopsy showed much of the same findings. Edit Edit source History Talk (0) Trending pages. She didnt really mess with too many peopleI dont understand how people could do somebodys child, mother, niece like that.. Missing. system, without permission from Dr. Maurice Godwin. While driving on a country road, Godfrey encountered an unidentified diamond-shaped flying object. to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really One of his previous residences was also near a soccer field where one of the victims, Elizabeth Smallwood, was found. Unsolved Murder Files; Unsolved Mystery Files; Legend Files; Suggested Cases; The Investigators; Contributing. Over the years, there have been reported sightings of August Mayfords ghost on the street corner where he was last seen. Whether this is labeled a homicide. Apparently the owners had planned to renovate but hadnt gotten around to it. Christina frequently called her kids and talked to them on every birthday, but in the fall of 2014, she stopped reaching out to them. March 21, 1976 Willie Kinlaw, unknown age, unknown cause of death. In every homicide, people are affected and many lives are changed forever. Following the shooting, an angry mob arrived at the scene, and the situation escalated into a riot. Rhonda Jones, Megan Oxendine, and Christina Bennett were 3 women dealing with their own demons when each of them were found dead. Because its obvious they didnt place themselves there. (Also the last place Cynthia was seen. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. June 3, 1997 Rachel McArthur, 29, blow to the head. Weve had analysts working this. Ginny Durham, the slain couple's daughter, thanked investigators. When more cops arrived at the scene, a fight broke out in the reception area, and most of the officers were locked outside. There is a growing disconnect in many major cities between police and the community they serve, especially in the African American communities in the aftermath of events like the murder of George Floyd, Hargrove said. Robin Warder is a budding Canadian screenwriter who has used his encyclopedic movie knowledge to publish numerous articles at Cracked.com. A 9 year old leaves her house in the middle of the night and disappeared. Were in a war when you think of homicide as a conflict, and we dont have enough boots on the ground, Hargrove said. Nov. 18, 1977 Johnny Strickland, unknown age, unknown cause of death. At approximately 5:00 AM on November 28, 1980, Constable Alan Godfrey of the West Yorkshire Metropolitan Police Force was investigating a report about a missing herd of cattle near the town of Todmorden. In 1927, Elwood Gainor worked as a police lieutenant in Lancaster, Pennsylvania. The victim's depicted in this deck are someone's mother, father, sister, brother, wife, husband or child. We have many Megan Oxendines family has been the most outspoken so we have more information on her, but heres what we know about Christina Bennett. On March 19, 2004, Brianna Maitland closed out her shift at the Black Lantern Inn around 11:20 P.M. and climbed into her car. I might rest a little while, but I wont never stop. She also said, Its killing me. (Solved Serial Killer Samuel McCullum). Drive was shot to death in the 2300 block of Murchison Road on Jan. 13, 1990. Ossie Herring of 407-B Bryan St. was If you have information about this case, call the Kernersville Police Department (336) 996-3177. Weve had behavioral analysis unit working days. and Murchison Road on Jan. 14, 1991. On April 17th, 2017, Rhonda was supposed to have a court date to get visitation. He has been a guest speaker on numerous national radio and television stations and is a five time published author. She was too decomposed. She was a white female, approximately 5'4" in height, with blue eyes, and brown hair. Authorities have called in the Behavioral Analysis Unit to help them get an idea of what kind of suspect they are dealing with. GIBSON, Jose Luis & Alonso For comparison, Pinehurst (1.5 hours away) the crime rate is 69.7% lower than the national rate and 72.5% lower than the North Carolina crime rate. 339 Vanstory St. was shot to death as he stepped from his car at his home on Following is the list of unsolved murders under the jurisdiction of the Her mom called her multiple times without getting an answer and by that night her calls were going straight to voicemail. Watauga County Sheriff Len Hagaman said the department investigated new leads and interviewed Davis in person in September 2019, October 2020 and August. The body was over a guardrail, approximately 15 feet down an embankment, just east of the New Hope Church Road exit. Detectives guessed that he was also connected to the rest of the so called Seven Bridges Murders because he was proven to have visited that area often and even lived there with his grandparents for years. For years, the people behind the crime remained a mystery. was beaten he drowned in College Lake on Sept. 9, 1991. list of unsolved murders between 1972 and 2000 in Fayetteville and Cumberland the Murderpedia project stay alive. The White County Sheriffs Office contacted the Watauga County Sheriffs Office in May 2019 about the information. On the morning of April 14, 1972, New York Police Department officers Philip Cardillo and Vito Navarra responded to a call for assistance from Detective Thomas of the 28th Precinct. The call originated from the second floor of Mosque Number 7 in Harlem, the New York headquarters of the Nation of Islam. You can also call the Crime Stoppers Tip Line at 919-683-1200. William McKoy, 52, of 418-A Vanstory If you have information about this case or any unsolved case in North Carolina, please contact the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation, (800) 334-3000. The fact that we have consulted with so many different departments. It seemed plausible that Wiley could have staged his disappearance, as he had gotten divorced from his wife the previous year and expressed a desire to retire from police work in order to become a writer. Investigators interviewed two sources to corroborate evidence from the crime scene. If you have information about this caseor any unsolved case in North Carolina, please contact the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation,(800) 334-3000. Rhonda Jones, Megan Oxendine, and Christina Bennett were 3 women dealing with their own demons when each of them were found dead. Faith Hedgepeth was a UNC sophomore when she was killed on Sept. 7, 2012. Aug. 1, 1987 Brenda Melvin, 26, strangulation. Source: Fayetteville Police Department. To this day, there have been no leads and no suspects, but there have been a number of other missing and murdered women in Lumberton whos disappearances and deaths continue to be unsolved. One focus of the investigation was the description of the vehicle driven by the suspect. Thomas Hargrove, founder of the Murder Accountability Project, suggested Monday on NewsNations Rush Hour that the reason for the low clearance rate is simple: there arent enough people to solve them. Investigation prompts missing persons policy change, Effects linger from wrongful accusation in Norfolk, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. On April 19, 1988, two armed assailants entered the Suncrest, Washington, home of Doyle Wheeler, a former officer from the San Diego Police Department. Another possible suspect was a former sheriffs officer who had recently been suspended by OMara for alcohol-related problems, but he was never interviewed and died six months later. And thats all I can say., Theres no change to the investigation. He had been shot in the forehead, and his gun was found near his right hand. The State Bureau of Investigation (SBI) Cold Case Investigation Team (CCIT) was founded in 2020. After reviewing the information received and re-interviewing witnesses, investigators believe the offender was driving a full-size pick-up truck of unknown color. His body was $20,000 REWARD for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person (s) responsible for the murder of Brittany Lynn Locklear. Photos of Deborah Gail Nunnery in 1980s including with her 4-year-old son who was also tragically murderedlater in his life. [2] Shortly thereafter, two sets of keys were found inside the stores closet. There is a Governor's reward of $5,000 for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person or persons responsible. Rhonda Jones originally wasnt from Lumberton either. Her toxicology showed cocaine, antihistamines, cough medication, an ingredient in Prozac, and nicotine. John Skaggs, a retired homicide detective for the Los Angeles Police Department, told The Guardian a lack of experienced personnel is a contributing factor. Sheila believes wholeheartedly that these 3 murders are connected. Oct. 2, 1993 Joe McAlister, unknown age, shot. What if a police officer becomes the center of their own unsolved mystery? June 30, 1990 Shelby Williams, 32, strangulation. 910-343-1131; 910-399-6137; cuecenter@aol.com; Location. He said he was very close with his father and recalled a story Birt had told him during a prison visit, when he admitted to killing three people in the North Carolina mountains during a heavy snowstorm, remembering that they almost got caught.. Feb. 7, 1981 Jerome Johnson, 58, unknown cause of death. 40% of the countys population are members of the Lumbee Indian tribe (a state recognized tribe 2 of the 3 victims were Lumbee) and more than 68% of the population are American Indian, black, and hispanic. Police continue to seek the public's help for any information, however seemingly unimportant or already reported, which may identify the person(s) responsible for the abduction and murder of Brittany Lynn Locklear. Laurence Tomlinson, 50, died on Nov. 3, 1994, after he was found unconscious February 14, 2000. Other women who were found dead before Christina, Rhonda, and Megan were never solved, and it was said that there was no evidence they were connected to these 3 murders. We simply lack the necessary resources to properly investigate major crimes.. July 6, 2003 Valarie Kirk, 34, shot. AUTOPSY: An autopsy was performed upon the body being brought, The Disappearance of Nguyet Thu Wiki Phung, Case Update: Brittanee Drexels Remains Discovered After 13 Years, Suspect Charged, The Disappearances of Tina & Bethany Sinclair. Sept. 15, 1985 Angelo Miles, 16, handgun. The most bizarre aspect of the story was the note that Wheeler was forced to write, in which he apologized for his prior testimony against another San Diego police officer named Donovan Jacobs. She was discovered on May 30th, 2005, and an autopsy revealed that her cause of death was blunt force trauma to the head and that she also suffered multiple stab wounds. I am also a big true crime junkie so I am eager to hear more of your opinions on these cases. nc Found inside the home were her two daughters, ages 4 and 18 months. Maybe the road was used by several unconnected killers to dispose of the evidence of their crimes. Physical evidence from both the abduction site and the body recovery site was sent to the SBI Laboratory for processing. We are dedicated and relentlessly pursue offenders, seeking justice for these victims of unsolved crimes. After that, the investigation into Elwood Gainors murder hit a complete standstill. Wiley even claimed he had been working on a novel, but investigators could never find any manuscript for it. Dating back to the 1500's, here are seven of the most infamous unsolved mysteries in North Carolina. 1993 Unknown male, unknown age, unknown cause of death. After an intensive search, her body was located the following day in a drainage ditch next to a farm road approximately three miles from where Brittany was last seen alive. Even though it was raining, there was a large unexplained large dry spot in the middle of the wet road. North Carolina: The Edgecombe County Serial Killer. Two months later, the burned remnants of the blue sedan were found in Queens. In recent years, there have been allegations that the FBIs COINTELPRO program could have orchestrated the fake distress call in an attempt to discredit the Nation of Islam. Their cases have never been completely explained. EARLY LIFE: Jessica Lynn Garino grew up the youngest of three children in Unicoi County, Tennessee. Your chances of being raped, assaulted, or killed were 1 in 55 based on data from 2016. I hope the criminals will be found in the end, thank you for sharing this story! I had to cremate my daughter. However, the police dont think that Abbys disappearance is linked to Christina, Rhonda, and Megan because, she wasnt out on the streets.. The same amount of resources and I think the fact that we have the reward out there. In fact, only months later, the body of 28-year-old Megan Ann Oxendine would be found nude in the yard of another abandoned home in the same 4 block radius. Ten victims were recovered at the burial site, all of which were African American women who were involved in prostitution and drug abuse. The investigation into Coniff's murder went nowhere and seemed destined to remain unsolved until it made an unlikely return to the spotlight over 50 years later. Terrace was strangled to death. When his body was found, he still had his main set of keys in his pocket. Feel free to contact him here. Rhonda Jones mother, Sheila Price has a memorial near where her daughters body was found. However, Ralstin passed away several months later at the age of 90, so the murder of George Coniff officially remains unsolved. The body was over a guardrail, approximately 15 feet down an embankment, just east of the New Hope Church Road exit. During the Great Depression, these were considered valuable commodities for criminals who dealt in black-market food. Input your search keywords and press Enter. 1972/1973 Barbara Baldwin, unknown age, unknown cause of death. May 7, 2019 . Oct. 13, 1996 Gaylord Johnson, unknown age, shot. June 18, 2003 Marc Michaels, 51, knife. The killings are listed according to the date of the murder, the name of victim(s), their age and how they were killed. Wheeler believed that the attempt on his life was a revenge scheme orchestrated by Jacobs or other members of the San Diego PD for his whistle-blowing. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. Weve had behavioral analysis unit working days. The grisly triple murder of a man, a woman and their son found slain in a bathtub in 1972 has been solved 50 years later, thanks to information from a Georgia inmate, the Watauga County Sheriffs Office in Boone, North Carolina, announced. A cold case went unsolved for more than a decade, and now a former North Carolina soldier is charged with murder. Oct. 3, 1980 Jefferson Dildy Jr., unknown age, unknown cause of death. April 5, 1984 Richard Pursel, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Lyall Hart was first reported missing by local sheriff's deputies as a vanishing. Many, if not most should be considered armed and dangerous. Joshua Aaron Richardson, who was stationed at the Fort Bragg military base at the . I know that they sacrificed many days and weekends in order to work on solving this case since 1972, she said, noting that some officers continued to work on the case even in retirement. She also created a group called Shatter the Silence that started as a Facebook group in 2018 and is now working on getting nonprofit status. Oct. 13, 1991 David Bracy, 47, shot. Godfrey was also surprised to discover that approximately 30 minutes had passed, but he had no memory of what happened. Sept. 6, 1980 Lee Shumway, 22, Robyn Shumway, 18, Shari Hill, 17, Shaun Michael A CBS News analysis of the FBI data published last year found that murders of white victims were about 30% more likely to be solved than in cases with Hispanic victims, and about 50% more than when the victims were Black. Oct. 15, 1996 Mark Blackman, 19, handgun. The BAU said that this suspect may have left the community after the murders and if they didnt leave they likely changed their behavior or MO. She was last seen on July 27, 2017 on Chippewa Street. At this time it was the most dangerous city in North Carolina. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. The case got progressively stranger, as three separate investigators were killed by gunshot wounds to the head. Multiple agencies, including the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation, the Boone Police Department, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation and the Appalachian State University Police Department, were also involved in the case. Her mom even thought that maybe Megan knew something about Rhondas murder, because after Rhonda died, Megan began acting differently. I aint gonna stop fighting. July 17, 1972 Ethel Kinlaw and Rebecca Parker, unknown ages, unknown cause of Where Pinehurst is the mecca of golf (where the PGA has been held and is home to the number 2 golf course) with a high population of wealthier households of doctors and other specialists, Lumbertons population is much more disadvantaged. She hasnt been seen or heard from since and her body has never been found. Virginia had died by strangulation, and Bryce and Bobby had been drowned, according to the newspaper. Unfortunately, these three women arent the only unsolved or missing persons cases in this relatively small town. Faith Hedgepeth Murder. After a long break from posting, were going to be looking at an especially interesting case out of North Carolina. The Robeson County Sheriff, Burnis Wilkins didnt appreciate the way the previous administration dealt with the cases of the disenfranchised and a 2005 investigation caused 22 people to lose their jobs. 1990. BAU suggested that the suspect may have started drinking heavily and may have quit their job. She was discovered on May 30th, 2005, and an autopsy revealed that her cause of death was blunt force trauma to the head and that she also suffered multiple stab wounds. Last updated February 13, 2023. Sept. 27, 1987 Rebecca Thompson, 19, handgun. This aint my job. Her family began to express concern for Jessicas well-being after she entered into a relationship with a, EARLY LIFE: Jamie Michelle Fraley was born on March 5, 1986 in Gaston County, North Carolina. The first victim reported missing was 29-year-old Melody Wiggins. These women phoned the Lancaster police to report the sedans license number, which likely explains Gainors exit from the station that night. Some of the most infamous North Carolina murders that remain unsolved include the 1998 abduction and murder of Brittany Locklear, the 1971 double murder of Patricia Mann and Jesse McBane, as well as many well-known disappearances throughout North Carolina. Since crime was virtually nonexistent on Bald Head Island, there was fear that rumors about murder and drug activity might have a negative effect on the communitys property values. She is 57 and when she disappeared she weighed 140 lbs. July 9, 1974 Anthony King, unknown age, unknown cause of death. photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and retrieval As a result, crucial evidence, including a bloody palm print on the back of Joness truck, was completely destroyed when the scene was hosed down. Im already obsessed with your blog. June 10, 1979 Earnest Garrett, unknown age, unknown cause of death. No one knows if Schirmer actually experienced this alien encounter, but a small piece of unexplained molten metal was found at that intersection. We are still putting the same amount of effort into this. If you have information about this caseor any unsolved case in North Carolina, please contact the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation,(800) 334-3000. Since OMara spent a portion of his career taking down the Illinois mafia, one theory was that his death was a revenge killing. Last updated: May 11, 2009 March 29, 1976 Nellie Hair, unknown age, blunt force. David Jackson D.O.H. April 12, 1984 Daniel Callahan, unknown age, unknown cause of death. These items were eventually traced to Joe Deano, a New York mobster who was heavily involved in bootlegging. Im not giving up. If you have information about this case, call the Windsor Police Department (252) 794-3111. Jimmie Riddle, 24, a resident of a mobile home park off Country Club Drive, I havent lived since this happenedIm so mad and angry and tired. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. If you come across them, do not attempt to apprehend them yourself. The medical examiner was unable to rule out things like strangulation or compression because she wasnt able to accurately identify damage to the soft tissue. Rebecca Ann Thompson, 17, of 224 Its been theorized that Jones could have been killed while interrupting a drug transaction. His grandparents house was just a few miles from where several of the bodies were found. She grew up in Pembroke only 12 miles from Lumberton with her 2 sisters. He quickly returned to the police station and wrote in his logbook that he had seen a flying saucer. Even though he was 66 years old, August Mayford was employed by the Alton, Illinois, police department as a special patrolman and merchants watchman for the downtown business district. She has the name Chris tattooed on her chest. Sept. 4, 1994 Herman Lee Locke, 20, shot. The driver was investigated and was determined to be a friend who dropped her off at a different location. On the evening of September 15, Coniff saw two men breaking into a local creamery to steal cheese and butter. Nov. 3, 2001 Antwone Jones, 23, shot. Dec. 27, 1991 Steven Richie, 19, shot. You hear every cop saying, We cant do better because they dont cooperate,' Skaggs said, But these young cops dont know how to talk to people and get them to cooperate.. Oct. 5, 1990 Evelyn Huggins, unknown age, unknown cause of death. CCIT falls under the Field Operation Division of the SBI and is responsible for assisting local and federal law enforcement investigations with unresolved homicides, missing persons and unidentified individuals in the state. May 30, 1980 Carl Purcell March, unknown age, unknown cause of death. She was later diagnosed with bipolar and anxiety disorders. Sept. 18, 1987 Learies Carter, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Allison Jackson Foy. On June 3, 2017, Megans nude body was found under branches and roof shingles in the unmowed brush of another abandoned house at 608 E. 8th Street, just about 500 feet from where the bodies of Christina and Rhonda were found. They rendered him unable to do his job, and he promptly resigned. Unsolved Homicide. Gillian, this was so interesting!